News24
18 Aug 2019, 17:43 GMT+10
The new National Credit Amendment Bill mentions in its preamble that there are consumers within South Africa for whom existing insolvency measures are inaccessible. This bill is meant to provide a solution, but fails to consider the consequences of those it aims to protect.
To fall within its ambit, consumers must earn a gross income of R7 500 or less per month, have unsecured debt of R50 000, or have been found to be critically indebted. They will be able to first apply for debt intervention before having their debt extinguished.
According to the Southern Africa Labour and Development Research Unit's income comparison tool, some 90% of South African households are earning less than R7 500 per month. Estimates of debt that could be written off range in size from R13-R20bn.
These households use credit to manage volatile incomes and expenses within any given month. Credit forms an integral part of financial management and is available both formally and informally.
Unfortunately, the bill is likely to set off a dangerous series of events. First, the lending risk is heightened as the bill incentivises bad behaviour by borrowers in the form of non-repayment or taking on credit they can't afford. To compensate for this, formal lenders will look to hike interest rates and/or reduce the volume of credit extension to this cohort.
With consumers battling the effects of a harsh economic climate, rising living costs and low job security, a lack of formal credit and more expensive formal credit will force this group to look elsewhere.
This leads borrowers to the informal credit market. A market which is not governed by this bill or other credit relevant regulations of the country.
A study by Wonga found that the prevalence of informal credit from 'mashonisas' or loan sharks sees one mashonisa per 100 households in low-income areas. This is arguably better penetration than seen by formal structures.
5 questions on the 'debt relief bill' unpackedNew debt relief bill poses a financial risk to economy and consumersBanks worried over new SA law giving clients debt relief
Mashonisas offer a local option, quick payout, no formal documents and ease of understanding. On the flip side, these loans do not qualify for debt relief, typically charge between 30 - 50% interest on loans, can seize belongings of and humiliate borrowers in their communities.
Studies also show that the informal market has insufficient liquidity to adequately provide to this group. Reaping the benefits of demand outstripping supply, Mashonisas can also raise their rates.
Affected consumers risk ending up in a worse position as these events play out seeing people struggling to pay for food, transport, and unplanned events. A more responsible approach may have seen formal lenders considering the context of the low-income community, looking abroad at alternative lending models, and implementing harsher restrictions to avoid and rectify reckless lending in both formal and informal structures.
This bill, unfortunately, does not promote a more inclusive lending environment.
Get a daily dose of Sierra Leone Times news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Sierra Leone Times.
More InformationLONDON/NEW YORK/CHICAGO: In suburban Chicago, just 15 minutes from O'Hare International Airport, a small customs brokerage quietly...
NEW YORK, New York, - U.S. stocks were split, but little moved Wednesday after a positive start to the week heralded by a two-day rally....
NEW YORK CITY, New York: Elon Musk is taking a big step toward making his long-promised robotaxi dream a reality. Over the weekend,...
PLANO, Texas: Toyota Motor will raise prices across a range of vehicles in the United States starting next month, the Japanese automaker...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: U.S. business activity showed signs of softening in June while inflationary pressures continued to build, driven...
NEW YORK, New York - U.S. stock markest closed sharply higher on Tuesday as a truce entered into between Irsael and Iran after 12 days...
(250626) -- MATOLA, June 26, 2025 (Xinhua) -- Soldiers attend a grand ceremony to commemorate the 50th anniversary of Mozambique's...
New Delhi [India], June 26 (ANI): External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar extended greetings to Madagascar on the occasion of the 65th...
Israel's Mossad chief says operations in Iran to continue David Barnea, chief of Israel's Mossad intelligence agency, said the organization...
London [UK], June 26 (ANI): Global leaders and advocates gathered at the Commonwealth Secretariat in London on Tuesday for the International...
Harare [Zimbabwe], June 25 (ANI): Zimbabwe women's team will make their historic debut in the ICC Women's Championship and embark on...
(250625) -- BULAWAYO, June 25, 2025 (Xinhua) -- A trader from Zimbabwe showcases leather products at a trade fair in Bulawayo, Zimbabwe,...