News24
12 May 2021, 23:42 GMT+10
A judge in London ruled that gym chain Virgin Active can wipe out the rent arrears on most of its venues and avoid future steep payments, despite the opposition of a majority of its creditors.
The decision represents a victory for tenants and a blow for landlords, with other companies now likely to seek a reduction in their debt pile using the same tool. Rent arrears have been building since March last year when non-essential businesses were forced to close or operate with restrictions due to the pandemic.
During the hearings, the company owned by JSE-listed Brait and billionaire Richard Branson argued that without the plan it would go into administration; a worse outcome for most classes of creditors. (Virgin Active South Africa is also owned by Brait, but operates separately from the UK business.)
In response, the landlords - Aberdeen Standard Investments, British Land, Land Securities Group and a fund managed by Knight Frank Investment Management - said that the company could have tried other options, such as selling the business or some assets, to tackle the situation.
Ultimately, Judge Richard Snowden ruled that with the restructuring plan "no member of a dissenting class will be any worse off than they would be in the relevant alternative".
Virgin Active celebrated the ruling as a fair solution that will allow the gym chain to "emerge from the crisis as a stronger business".
Landlords, however, expressed concern about the wider implications of the ruling.
"This restructuring plan sets a dangerous precedent and demonstrates how the law is now allowing wealthy individuals and private equity backers to extract value from their businesses in good times but later claim insolvency," wrote Melanie Leech, chief executive of British Property Federation, in an emailed statement.
While the Covid-19 pandemic has brought hardship to businesses, "it has also been cynically used as an excuse to shift onto property owners the cost of years of failings and underinvestment", Leech added.
Virgin Active is the first company to use insolvency rules approved last year which force landlords to accept losses even when fewer than three-quarters of the firm's creditors agree. UK car park operator NCP is now seeking relief for its rental costs under the same criteria.
The gym group's rent bill is set to reach 30 million pounds (R560 million) by the end of May, according to court documents.
Prior to the pandemic, the UK's standard restructuring tool to deal with unsecured creditors like landlords consisted of a company voluntary arrangement, which requires approval by 75% of relevant creditors.
Under the so-called "cross-class cramdown" rule, companies just need one class of creditors to support the restructuring, but still require court approval for their plans.
A government-imposed moratorium on forfeiture action, preventing landlords from taking control of the asset if the tenant fails to pay, has been in place for more than a year and is set to be lifted in June.
The Virgin Active case represents a huge victory for landlords and more companies will consider this tool now that there is more certainty about how a court will see certain approaches, according to Ian Corfield, a restructuring partner at FRP Advisory. Going forward, landlords will have to be more creative to avoid the imposition of losses by a minority of creditors.
"These are the rules, and the only way to change them is by constant challenge, constant evolution and coming up with more creative solutions," said Corfield.
Get the biggest business stories emailed to you every weekday.
Go to the Fin24 front page.
Get a daily dose of Sierra Leone Times news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Sierra Leone Times.
More InformationWASHINGTON, D.C.: As the global weight-loss market explodes, drugmakers are now racing to solve a less visible problem: protecting...
HAYWARD, California: In a significant step toward its commercial debut, Amazon-owned Zoox has unveiled its first factory dedicated...
SAO PAULO, Brazil: Brazil is taking confident steps to restore its dominance in global poultry exports after declaring its commercial...
NEW YORK, New YorK - U.S. stocks closed mixed on Friday, with gains and losses modest, as investors and traders weighed up the escalation...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: Retail sales dropped sharply in May as consumer spending slowed after a strong start to the year, primarily due to...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: Mitsubishi Motors is the latest automaker to raise prices in the United States, joining a growing list of car companies...
JOHANNESBURG, South Africa: A key global plan to end AIDS as a public health threat by 2030 is now in deeper jeopardy after the United...
Leeds [UK] June 21 (ANI): India could not properly capitalise on the three centuries by its batters in the first innings of first Test...
Islamabad has cited the US presidents role in ending the latest Pakistan-India escalation The Pakistani government has formally recommended...
New Delhi [India], June 21 (ANI): RJD MP Manoj Kumar Jha on Saturday stated that Parliament must speak in a collective voice on the...
Bridgetown [Barbados], June 21 (ANI): For Australia's young swashbuckler Sam Konstas, the biggest challenge wasn't the batting aspect...
BEIJING, June 21 (Xinhua) -- China's 618 mid-year online shopping festival wrapped up this week, capping a brisk first half for the...